Browse Client Types

Browse past lab clients by general industry sectors

Trial Number 3

Trial Purpose:

To evaluate the ears of removal of adhesive using a variety of scrubbing tools

Date Run:

03/27/2024

Experiment Procedure:

Five scrubbing tools were tested compared to paper towels as a reference.  A total of eighteen laminate coupons were used, three per tool.  The initial weights of the coupons were recorded.  The coupons were then soiled with Roberts Vinyl Composition Floor Adhesive by heating the adhesive with a heat gun for 5 seconds, and then scraping the melted adhesive onto the center of the coupons.  The dirty weights of the coupons were then recorded.  Each coupon was cleaned with the correct scrubbing tool with Krud Kutter until all of the adhesive was removed. Each coupon received 2 sprays of the Krud Kutter and each tool received 2 sprays of the Krud Kutter, meaning that for each coupon about 3 ml of the cleaning agent was used. The time it took for all of the adhesive to be removed was recorded.  

Trial Results:

Tool Wt of cont. Time cleaned (secs) Time required per gram of cont. AVG Time (secs) AVG Time
Microfiber Towel 0.5921 80 145 165 2:45
0.4912 68 154
0.5309 88 196
Cleaning Solutions Soft Touch Scouring Pad 0.4691 27 57 60 1:00
0.4965 34 68
0.8067 46 56
Hannaford Non Scratch Scrubber Sponges 0.8876 54 61 72 1:12
1.5201 83 55
1.0127 100 99
Dawn Heavy Duty Scouring Pads 0.9254 127 149 162 2:42
0.8309 79 178
0.5419 54 160
Scrub Daddy 0.8668 43 50 51 0:51
1.3215 67 51
0.2598 51 52
Paper Towel (reference) 0.6589 96 163 164 2:44
0.9408 134 157
0.8246 124 171

Non of the scrubbing tools caused any scratching or destruction of the substrate.  The Dawn Heavy Duty Scouring Pads left green residue from the sponge.  The microfiber towel is too absorbent, it absorbed too much of the cleaner for it work effectively.

Success Rating:

Results successful using TACT (time, agitation, concentration, and temperature, as well as rinsing and drying) and/or other cleaning chemistries examined.

Conclusion:

The scrub daddy sponges were able to remove all of the adhesive the quickest out of the tools, with an average of a 51 second cleaning time per gram of soil.  The Dawn Heavy Duty Scouring Pads are not effective due to the residue left behind.  

Save Report as a PDF